Changing Platforms

You are here: Home > Forum > Simulations > Released > Wolverhampton > Changing Platforms

Page 1 of 1

Changing Platforms 07/02/2016 at 18:23 #80454
Aston
Avatar
9 posts
Just a general query really, but I was on Wolverhampton sim so I will post it here.

Do you get marked down on your score if you change a trains default platform?

I had a late running train which was behind another service, both trains needed to use platform 1 and go up the Trent valley.

I had a space on platform 2 so decided rather than holding the delayed service outside the station that I would bring it into platform 2.

I did this so that the service wouldn't be delayed any longer but I think I got marked down because I used the wrong platform.

Is it the right thing to do? Or should I just hold it outside the station so that it gets delayed by even longer?

Log in to reply
Changing Platforms 07/02/2016 at 18:37 #80455
JamesN
Avatar
1570 posts
Online
" said:
Just a general query really, but I was on Wolverhampton sim so I will post it here.

Do you get marked down on your score if you change a trains default platform?

I had a late running train which was behind another service, both trains needed to use platform 1 and go up the Trent valley.

I had a space on platform 2 so decided rather than holding the delayed service outside the station that I would bring it into platform 2.

I did this so that the service wouldn't be delayed any longer but I think I got marked down because I used the wrong platform.

Is it the right thing to do? Or should I just hold it outside the station so that it gets delayed by even longer?
Yes, you were marked down.

As to whether it was the "right" thing? That depends... The score, for the most part reflects how accurately followed the timetable - but to get round failures and disruption you need to re-platform trains, skip stops etc etc. So from A realism point of view what you did was fine...

Some people obsess over the score, but the train ends up so late waiting for its platform any points "gained" using correct platform are negated by those lost for it being 20 minutes late as a result...

Log in to reply
The following user said thank you: Aston
Changing Platforms 07/02/2016 at 18:41 #80456
Aston
Avatar
9 posts
" said:
" said:
Just a general query really, but I was on Wolverhampton sim so I will post it here.

Do you get marked down on your score if you change a trains default platform?

I had a late running train which was behind another service, both trains needed to use platform 1 and go up the Trent valley.

I had a space on platform 2 so decided rather than holding the delayed service outside the station that I would bring it into platform 2.

I did this so that the service wouldn't be delayed any longer but I think I got marked down because I used the wrong platform.

Is it the right thing to do? Or should I just hold it outside the station so that it gets delayed by even longer?
Yes, you were marked down.

As to whether it was the "right" thing? That depends... The score, for the most part reflects how accurately followed the timetable - but to get round failures and disruption you need to re-platform trains, skip stops etc etc. So from A realism point of view what you did was fine...

Some people obsess over the score, but the train ends up so late waiting for its platform any points "gained" using correct platform are negated by those lost for it being 20 minutes late as a result...

Thanks for the clarification mate, appreciate it.

Log in to reply
Changing Platforms 07/02/2016 at 19:47 #80457
AndyG
Avatar
1830 posts
Or if you are points chasing, edit the platform number of the train in question before it arrives (so that correct information is given out to the expectant passengers.
I can only help one person a day. Today's not your day. Tomorrow doesn't look too good either.
Log in to reply
Changing Platforms 07/02/2016 at 20:41 #80458
Hawk777
Avatar
386 posts
Note that, given the choice, it’s better to select a different platform number that’s attached to the same physical platform (i.e. blob of orange on-screen). That way waiting passengers just have to turn around, not run across bridges or whatever. That’s why the performance analysis window differentiates between “wrong platform” and “opposite platform” and takes fewer points off for the latter.
Log in to reply
Changing Platforms 08/02/2016 at 12:12 #80464
Banners88
Avatar
107 posts
The way I look at it is that as the signaller you would need to inform the platform staff at a place like Wolves to help with assisting passengers and changing information screens.

Just think of changing the platform numbers in the timetable as calling down to the control room or informing platform staff.

Win for your performance score and win for those passengers sheltering in the rain!

Log in to reply